When we returned from our stroll, we were greeted by a man at the door of Holmes's estate. We shook hands, and Holmes introduced him as Mr. Helming, a friendly neighbour with whom he often exchanged ideas. Mr. Helming had an air of congeniality, was surprisingly soft-spoken for a Teutonic man, and was all-in-all pleasant company. He was elderly, and had retired to the countryside with his wife approximately a decade before Holmes had settled there, having moved to England for some business prospect before then. Holmes invited him in for lunch, and the German produced a still-warm loaf from the basket by his feet as a contribution.
"Mr. Helming here has been most helpful with my burgeoning efforts in bee-keeping," explained Mr. Holmes as we all three trooped through his door for a spot of lunch. "Give here the loaf, Mr. Helming. Yes, thank you. I'm afraid I shall have to leave the two of you to your own devices while I prepare our sustenance. Helming, I'm sure you won't mind the good doctor's pestering you with a few avenues of discussion?"
"Not at all."
With a small tipping of his head, Holmes disappeared into the kitchen and could be heard blustering about within. Helming and I settled into some armchairs and he produced a pipe. Having lit it, he turned to me. "Beg pardon for my lack of attention, Dr. Watson," he said with a smile. "Being of my advanced age renders concentration upon several matters at once a miserably difficult task."
I told him I felt no offence at all, and asked him about Holmes's allusion to his assistance in his efforts. Helming chuckled and puffed for a bit before shaking his head. "Your friend gives me too much credit, surely. I only instructed him on how to build his hives and gave general tips for maintaining the creatures, nothing more."
I was surprised. "I was under the assumption that the hives were bought."
"Well, they may be, but there's little like the feeling of successfully building a hive, and at least the first one must have been built by hand. I cannot attest for the others." Helming looked languidly out the window at the structures in Holmes's sprawling gardens. "I had the most horrific time debating with him the advantages of different hive systems. Oh, you did not know that there are other types? Well, there are, rest assured. When's there's a will to do one thing, and more than one man to do it, you can be sure that competing methods shall follow.
"What Holmes has here is denoted as a Langstroth Bee Hive. It is a structure of efficiency and ease of upkeep, patented approximately half a decade before. You see here," and Helming began to gesticulate, miming the different layers, "there is a bottom layer, a simple sheet of wood, upon which the rest of the structure is constructed. On this, there are several deeps - oh, my apologies, having been around enthusiasts, I hardly know how to curb my vocabulary. I am sure, my good doctor, that the same happens to you regarding medical terms? In any case, "deeps" are best described as the boxes, shelves, if you will, where the combs are hung. And to cover, there is a another piece of wood, which allows access to the bees, and a more solid lid on top of that, keeping out rain and other such elements."
"It appears a most efficient structure indeed."
"Yes, and it helps to give the bees a structure to their hives. The bottom levels are for the Queen Bee, where her eggs are laid and the young nurtured, and the top levels are used for honey, allowing us easy and minimally disruptive access to the food. It's a nice system, to be sure."
"I sense that you have a rebuttal of it; what system do you use?"
"Indeed I do. I suppose you have not heard of a top bar hive? I thought so! Don’t be apologetic, doctor, it’s perfectly fine. It is the structure which I use, and Holmes has often gotten into arguments with me regarding the pros and cons of each type. The top bar hive is an extremely simple structure, little more than a box with bars hanging across for the bees to build upon.
“It is my preferred method of keeping: I am an elderly man, and it is much easier on my back – I’m sure you’ve noticed that the Langstroth deeps are quite heavy? The top bar hive is an absolute Godsend for my back pains. It requires more time and management, but it is quite inexpensive and easy to construct. And of course, I believe it to be more aesthetically pleasing, and to see the bees hang their combs in whichever way they please is a joy in itself.”
“Are these the only methods?”
“Oh! Hardly, there are many, including a comfortable middle-ground of a Warre hive. Really, the only way to truly know which is best is to experiment with them.”
At this point, Holmes emerged from the kitchen, carrying a tray laden with food. “I hope you are both hungry? Helming, is the wife not joining us? No? That is a pity, send her my regards. Gather round, let us say grace.”
That done, we picked up our forks. Holmes smiled at Helming. “I trust you have been indoctrinating Watson with the advantages of a top bar hive?”
Helming laughed and I hurriedly assured that his account was most objective. Holmes put on serious airs and turned to me. “My dear Watson, believe not a word of this man’s narrative. Truly, the Langstroth is the superior structure. This man knows nothing.”
I was surprised at Holmes’s rudeness, but the tension was relieved by Helming laughing softly and retaliating. “Oh no, good doctor, I’ll have you know that Holmes is the one who is ignorant. Ever since writing his book he has become arrogant. The top bar hive can be the only hive worth having.”
Understanding that it was said in jest, I merely chuckled and turned back to my food as Holmes and Helming engaged each other in a mockingly serious debate regarding the subject.
- Dr. John H. Watson
------------------------------------------
Langstroth Hive Video
1) The screen on the bottom is a newer addition - which makes me wonder why they would use wood in the first place anyway, if it kept rotting.
2) The little boxes are called "deeps".
3) The Queen is very particular and must be in the bottom
Question: So if the Queen stays in the bottom of the Langstroth Hive, do they do that in nature? Would she still be in the bottom? Wouldn't that leave her more open and prone to attack from predators like bears, who generally swat at the hive's bottom?
To look for: If we have a screen or a block of wood on the bottom.
Langstroth vs. Top Bar Hive
1) Top Bar Hives are much better for developing countries, being very inexpensive
2) Helps those who have back pains to alleviate the pressure on their back.
3) TBH requires much more upkeep than Langstroth.
Question: If I want to start a hive in my own backyard, would a TBH or a Langstroth be better?
To look for: N/A